When AI Helps but Humans Feel Less Capable: The Impact of Generative AI Reliance on Professional Self-Efficacy and Meaningful Work

Authors

  • Muhammad Usman Siddqiue Assistant Professor School of Digital and Cinematic Arts, Institute for Art and Culture Lahore Pakistan
  • Syed Ali Sultan Assistant Professor, School of Digital and Cinematic Arts Institute for Art & Culture

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.69565/jess.v5i1.395

Keywords:

Generative AI reliance, professional self-efficacy, meaningful work, AI literacy, knowledge workers

Abstract

While generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has the potential to enhance knowledge work, the psychological impact of its use is not fully known. Based on Social cognitive theory and Self-determination theory, this study explores whether the use of GenAI erodes employees' professional self-efficacy and subsequently their meaningful work, and whether AI-literacy helps to protect against this negative trend. The three-wave time-lagged survey of 350 knowledge workers in Pakistan was analysed using composite-based regression (PROCESS Model 7) with bootstrapping method, which was cross-validated with PLS-SEM. Professional self-efficacy (β = −.277) and meaningful work (β = −.123) decreased with the dependence on GenAI. Professional self-efficacy was a significant predictor of meaningful work (β = .479) and accounted for half of the total effect (indirect effect = −.133). The indirect effect was reduced when AI literacy was low (−.199), but it became less negative and significant at high AI literacy (−.068; index of moderated mediation = .066). Results were consistent across the control variables, the PLS-SEM and the method-variance checks. The study moves the discussion about GenAI productivity to one about psychological cost, clarifies the role of self-efficacy in the link between reliance and meaningful work and introduces the concept of AI literacy as a trainable organisational shield.

Downloads

Published

2026-06-15

How to Cite

Siddqiue, M. U., & Sultan, S. A. (2026). When AI Helps but Humans Feel Less Capable: The Impact of Generative AI Reliance on Professional Self-Efficacy and Meaningful Work. Journal of Excellence in Social Sciences, 5(1), 1–17. https://doi.org/10.69565/jess.v5i1.395

Issue

Section

Articles