Post-Publication Correction and Retraction Policy
Journal of Excellence in Social Sciences (JESS)
The Journal of Excellence in Social Sciences (JESS) is committed to maintaining the accuracy, integrity, and transparency of the scholarly record.
The journal handles post-publication concerns through corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and, in exceptional circumstances, removal of content. These actions protect readers and the scholarly record rather than punish authors.
JESS follows relevant COPE guidance and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing.
1. Reporting Post-Publication Concerns
Authors, readers, reviewers, editors, and institutions may report errors or concerns about published content to jess@smarcons.com.
Reports should identify the article, describe the concern, and provide supporting evidence where available.
The journal assesses concerns fairly and confidentially. Authors are given an appropriate opportunity to respond. Where necessary, the journal seeks specialist advice or refers suspected misconduct to the relevant institution or competent authority.
2. Correction Notices
A correction is issued when an error affects the accuracy, interpretation, attribution, or completeness of an article but does not invalidate its principal findings or conclusions.
Corrections may address errors in data presentation, calculations, figures, tables, author information, funding statements, conflicts of interest, or other relevant disclosures.
JESS uses:
- Erratum: For an error introduced by the journal during editing or production.
- Corrigendum: For an error originating in the authors’ submitted material.
Each correction notice:
- Identifies the original article;
- Explains the error and the correction;
- States its publication date;
- Is freely accessible; and
- Is linked to the article, with a corresponding link from the article to the notice.
Where article files are updated, the change is identified and connected to the correction notice. Substantive changes are not made silently.
Minor typographical or formatting errors that do not affect meaning may be corrected without a separate notice.
3. Retractions
Retraction is considered when evidence establishes that an article’s findings cannot be relied upon or that a serious publication-integrity breach warrants retraction.
Grounds may include:
- Major errors that invalidate the principal findings;
- Fabricated or falsified data;
- Plagiarism;
- Redundant publication without appropriate disclosure or justification;
- Unauthorised use of material or data;
- Unethical research;
- Compromised or manipulated peer review; or
- An undisclosed major conflict of interest that materially affected assessment or interpretation.
An unsuccessful replication alone does not automatically justify retraction. The journal evaluates the evidence and its implications for the original findings.
An authorship dispute alone does not normally justify retraction where the findings remain reliable. Such disputes are addressed under the journal’s Author Credit Policy.
Retraction Notices
A retraction notice:
- Clearly identifies the article by title, authors, and DOI, where available;
- States who is retracting the article;
- Explains the reasons and evidential basis;
- Distinguishes established misconduct from honest error where possible;
- Uses factual, professional language;
- Is freely accessible; and
- Is linked to the original article, with a corresponding link from the article to the notice.
The article remains accessible and is clearly marked “Retracted” on its webpage and full-text files, except where exceptional removal is necessary under Section 6.
Author agreement is sought where appropriate but is not required for an evidence-based editorial decision to retract.
4. Expressions of Concern
JESS may publish an expression of concern when serious questions about an article’s reliability or ethical integrity exist, but the evidence is not yet sufficient for a final determination.
This may occur when an investigation is pending, substantially delayed, inconclusive, or unavailable.
The notice:
- Identifies the article;
- Explains the concern and the limits of the available evidence;
- Avoids presenting unproven allegations as established facts;
- Is freely accessible; and
- Is linked to the affected article.
The journal reviews the notice as further evidence becomes available. A subsequent notice communicates the outcome, whether it involves correction, retraction, or resolution without further action. Links between the notices preserve the history of the assessment.
5. Withdrawal Before Publication
Authors may request withdrawal of an unpublished submission by contacting the editorial office with the manuscript identifier and reason for withdrawal.
The corresponding author must confirm that all co-authors agree. The journal reviews and acknowledges the request and confirms the submission’s status.
Withdrawal does not automatically erase submission records. Relevant records may be retained confidentially for administrative and research-integrity purposes, subject to applicable privacy and retention requirements.
Once an article has been publicly published, including online-first publication, post-publication procedures apply rather than routine submission withdrawal.
6. Exceptional Removal of Published Content
Published articles are normally retained in the scholarly record, including after retraction.
Removal or restricted access is considered only in exceptional circumstances, such as:
- A court order or other binding legal requirement;
- Clearly defamatory content or another serious infringement of legal rights;
- A serious violation of personal privacy or confidentiality; or
- Content whose continued availability poses a serious health or safety risk.
Removal is not used merely because an author requests it, disagrees with a retraction, wishes to avoid criticism, or intends to publish the work elsewhere.
The Editor-in-Chief and publisher assess the circumstances, obtaining legal or specialist advice where appropriate. Limited redaction is considered where it can adequately address the problem without removing the entire article.
Where full text is removed:
- The article’s landing page and bibliographic metadata remain available to the extent legally and ethically permissible;
- A public notice explains the removal as fully as circumstances permit;
- The DOI continues to resolve to the retained record or notice; and
- Any related correction or retraction notice remains linked to that record.
Public notices must not reproduce the confidential or harmful information that required removal. Original files may be retained in a restricted archive only where lawful and appropriate.
7. Decision-Making and Conflicts of Interest
The Editor-in-Chief oversees post-publication assessment, consulting qualified editors, the publisher, independent specialists, or relevant institutions as necessary.
An editor with a relevant conflict of interest must not handle the case. The matter is assigned to an appropriately qualified person without that conflict.
The journal determines the appropriate action based on the evidence, the reliability of the published work, and applicable ethical and legal requirements.
8. Author Notification and Appeals
Authors are informed of substantive concerns and proposed actions and given an appropriate opportunity to respond.
Where urgent legal, privacy, or safety circumstances require immediate action, the journal may act before completing correspondence with all authors.
Authors may appeal by providing evidence of a factual error, procedural irregularity, or material information not previously considered. Appeals are assessed without relevant conflicts of interest.
An appeal does not automatically delay an action necessary to protect readers or comply with a binding requirement.
9. Metadata, Indexing, and Preservation
The journal updates article webpages, publication files, and relevant metadata to reflect corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or removals.
Relevant notices receive persistent identifiers where available. Updated information is supplied to Crossref, indexing services, repositories, and preservation services as supported by their procedures.
JESS does not guarantee that every third-party copy can be updated or removed. Its own publication record clearly communicates the current status.
10. Relationship with Other Policies
This policy operates alongside the journal’s:
- Publication Ethics Policy;
- Research Misconduct & Whistleblower Policy;
- Author Credit Policy;
- Peer Review Policy; and
- Digital Archiving Policy.
References to removal in other journal policies are subject to the exceptional circumstances and safeguards in Section 6.
11. Contact
Editorial Office
Journal of Excellence in Social Sciences (JESS)
Email: jess@smarcons.com