Research Misconduct & Whistleblower Policy
Journal of Excellence in Social Sciences (JESS)
Publisher: Society of Management research and consultancy (Smarcons)
Scope and reporting
JESS assesses suspected fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, undisclosed redundant publication, authorship abuse, citation manipulation, peer-review manipulation, undisclosed conflicts and unethical research. Authors, reviewers, editors, institutions and readers may report concerns to jess@smarcons.com. Reports should identify the work, explain the concern and supply relevant evidence. Credible anonymous reports are assessed on their evidence.
Independent handling
The Editor-in-Chief normally oversees initial assessment. Anyone with a relevant conflict must recuse themselves. Concerns involving the Editor-in-Chief or an unresolved editorial complaint may be sent directly to the Ethics Committee at ethics@smarcons.com. Appropriate mediation may be requested from the Ombudsperson at ombudsperson@smarcons.com. A conflicted committee member or mediator must not handle the case.
Fair assessment
The journal preserves relevant editorial records, assesses the evidence, seeks explanations and supporting documentation, and gives affected parties an appropriate opportunity to respond. Independent specialist advice may be obtained. Review or publication may be paused while material concerns remain unresolved. Allegations are not treated as established findings. Institutions or other competent bodies may be asked to investigate conduct or research records beyond the journal’s authority.
Confidentiality and whistleblower protection
Information is shared only as necessary for fair assessment, investigation or legal obligations. The journal seeks to protect good-faith reporters and prohibits retaliation within its editorial activities. Absolute confidentiality or anonymity cannot be guaranteed where disclosure is legally required or necessary to assess a case fairly; unnecessary identifying details will not be disclosed. Disagreement or criticism alone is not misconduct.
Outcomes
Depending on evidence and the reliability of the work, outcomes may include no further action, clarification, revision, rejection, correction, expression of concern, retraction or institutional referral. Published content is normally retained and marked appropriately. Exceptional removal follows the Post-Publication Correction and Retraction Policy. Any restriction on future participation must be proportionate, reasoned and communicated to those affected rather than imposed automatically.
Updates and appeals
JESS aims to acknowledge reports within 10 working days and provides updates where investigations take longer. An appeal must identify a factual error, procedural irregularity or material new evidence and is assessed without relevant conflicts. The detailed complaints and appeal arrangements in Publication Ethics apply. JESS follows relevant COPE guidance; this does not imply membership.