Research Misconduct & Whistleblower Policy

Research Misconduct Policy

The Journal of Personnel Management (JPM), published by SMARCONS (Society of Management Research and Consultancy), is committed to maintaining the integrity, transparency, accuracy, and reliability of the scholarly record.

JPM takes allegations of research misconduct, publication misconduct, editorial misconduct, and peer review misconduct seriously and follows recognized principles of publication ethics, including relevant guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

For the purposes of this policy, research and publication misconduct includes, but is not limited to:

  • Fabrication, falsification, or manipulation of research data, images, results, findings, or other research records

  • Plagiarism, including the use of text, ideas, data, images, figures, tables, or other scholarly material without appropriate acknowledgement

  • Inappropriate text recycling or self-plagiarism

  • Duplicate or redundant publication

  • Simultaneous submission of substantially the same manuscript to more than one journal

  • Misrepresentation of authorship, including ghost authorship, guest authorship, honorary authorship, or omission of legitimate contributors

  • Citation manipulation or inappropriate citation practices

  • Manipulation of the peer review process, including fabricated reviewer identities, false reviewer information, or attempts to influence reviewer selection improperly

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest, including financial, institutional, personal, professional, or academic conflicts

  • Failure to obtain required ethical approval for research involving human participants, animals, confidential information, or sensitive data

  • Misrepresentation or fabrication of ethical approval

  • Unauthorized alteration or manipulation of images or research materials

  • Selective reporting or deliberate misrepresentation of research findings

  • Misuse of confidential information obtained during the peer review or editorial process

  • Other conduct that compromises the integrity of the research or publication record

Handling Allegations of Misconduct

Allegations of suspected misconduct may be raised by:

  • Editors

  • Reviewers

  • Authors

  • Readers

  • Research institutions

  • Employers

  • Funding organizations

  • Ethics committees

  • Academic bodies

  • Other concerned individuals or organizations

All allegations will be handled as carefully, confidentially, fairly, and impartially as reasonably possible.

The Editor-in-Chief will normally conduct or oversee the initial assessment of an allegation.

Where appropriate, the Editor-in-Chief may consult:

  • Members of the editorial board

  • Independent subject experts

  • Research integrity specialists

  • The author’s institution

  • The reviewer’s institution

  • Funding organizations

  • Ethics committees

  • Other relevant authorities

JPM will follow relevant COPE guidance and the journal’s applicable publication-ethics policies when evaluating suspected misconduct.

Initial Assessment

When an allegation is received, the editorial office will first determine whether:

  • The concern falls within the journal’s responsibility

  • Sufficient information has been provided to evaluate the allegation

  • The allegation appears credible and warrants further investigation

  • Additional documentation or clarification is required

  • Immediate action is necessary to protect the integrity of the scholarly record

The journal will avoid reaching conclusions solely on the basis of allegations without considering relevant evidence.

Investigation Principles

During the assessment or investigation of suspected misconduct:

  • All parties will be treated fairly and professionally

  • Relevant information will be handled confidentially

  • The identity of a complainant or whistleblower will be protected as far as reasonably possible

  • Individuals against whom allegations are made will normally be given an appropriate opportunity to respond

  • Relevant documentary and other evidence will be reviewed before a final editorial decision is made

  • Conflicts of interest among individuals handling the allegation will be identified and appropriately managed

  • Independent expertise may be sought where necessary

  • Institutions, employers, funders, or ethics committees may be contacted where appropriate

JPM does not normally conduct institutional-level investigations into matters that require access to research records, laboratories, participant records, employment files, or other evidence beyond the journal’s authority.

Where appropriate, such matters may be referred to the responsible institution or other competent authority.

Evidence That May Be Reviewed

Depending on the nature of the allegation, the journal may review relevant materials including:

  • Submitted and published manuscript files

  • Similarity reports

  • Editorial correspondence

  • Peer review reports

  • Reviewer records

  • Authorship declarations

  • Conflict of interest disclosures

  • Ethics approval documentation

  • Research data or supporting files supplied to the journal

  • Images, figures, and tables

  • Previously published articles

  • Corrections or retractions relating to relevant work

  • Other documentary evidence relevant to the allegation

Additional information may be requested from authors, reviewers, editors, institutions, or complainants where necessary.

Actions in Proven or Substantiated Cases of Misconduct

Where misconduct is established or sufficiently substantiated, JPM may take one or more actions depending on the seriousness, nature, timing, and consequences of the matter.

Actions may include:

  • Rejecting the manuscript

  • Returning the manuscript for correction

  • Suspending editorial consideration while an investigation is underway

  • Requesting additional evidence or documentation

  • Requiring corrections before publication

  • Publishing a correction

  • Publishing an editorial notice

  • Publishing an Expression of Concern

  • Retracting a published article

  • Removing inappropriate material where permitted and properly documented

  • Correcting the publication record

  • Notifying the author’s institution or employer

  • Notifying a reviewer’s institution where appropriate

  • Contacting a funding organization, ethics committee, or other responsible body

  • Restricting future submissions from an individual where justified by serious misconduct

  • Removing an individual from reviewer or editorial responsibilities where appropriate

  • Taking other proportionate action necessary to protect the integrity of the journal and scholarly record

Any corrective action will be proportionate to the available evidence and seriousness of the case.

Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

Where misconduct affects a published article, JPM will take appropriate action to maintain the integrity and transparency of the scholarly record.

Depending on the circumstances, the journal may publish:

  • A Correction

  • An Expression of Concern

  • A Retraction Notice

  • Another appropriate editorial notice

Such notices will, where applicable:

  • Clearly identify the affected article

  • Explain the reason for the editorial action

  • Be linked to the original article

  • Remain permanently accessible

  • Preserve the scholarly record

  • Be reflected in relevant metadata where appropriate

Retractions and other post-publication actions will be handled in accordance with JPM’s Corrections and Retractions Policy and relevant publication-ethics guidance.

Whistleblower Policy

JPM encourages individuals to report credible concerns relating to research integrity, publication ethics, editorial conduct, or peer review.

Reports may be submitted by editors, reviewers, authors, readers, institutions, research staff, funding bodies, or other stakeholders.

Whistleblowers may raise concerns regarding matters including:

  • Plagiarism

  • Duplicate or redundant publication

  • Fabrication or falsification of data

  • Manipulation of images or results

  • Misrepresentation of research findings

  • Authorship misconduct

  • Ghost, guest, or honorary authorship

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest

  • Ethical approval concerns

  • Fabricated or misleading ethical approval information

  • Peer review manipulation

  • Fabricated reviewer identities

  • Citation manipulation

  • Breaches of peer review confidentiality

  • Editorial conflicts of interest

  • Misleading reporting

  • Unsupported or deliberately distorted conclusions

  • Other conduct that could compromise the scholarly record

Reporting a Concern

Reports should be made in good faith and should contain sufficient information to allow the journal to understand and assess the concern.

Where available, the report should include:

  • The title of the manuscript or article concerned

  • Names of relevant authors or other individuals

  • A clear description of the alleged concern

  • Relevant dates

  • Supporting evidence or documentation

  • Links to potentially duplicated or conflicting publications

  • Any other information that may assist the assessment

The absence of complete evidence does not automatically prevent a concern from being considered.

However, the journal must have enough information to make a meaningful initial assessment.

Anonymous Reports

JPM may consider anonymous reports where sufficient information and evidence are provided to allow the concern to be assessed.

Anonymous allegations may be more difficult to investigate if:

  • The available evidence is insufficient

  • Additional clarification is required

  • The journal cannot verify relevant details

  • The allegations depend primarily on unsupported assertions

The credibility and substance of the evidence will be considered regardless of whether the complainant identifies themselves.

Protection and Confidentiality

Whistleblower reports will be handled confidentially to the extent reasonably possible.

The identity of a whistleblower will not normally be disclosed unnecessarily.

Disclosure may, however, become necessary where required by:

  • Law

  • A formal institutional investigation

  • Regulatory requirements

  • Ethical obligations

  • Due process considerations

  • Other circumstances in which disclosure is necessary for an appropriate investigation

The journal will take reasonable steps to minimize unnecessary disclosure of a whistleblower’s identity.

Protection Against Retaliation

JPM does not tolerate retaliation against individuals who report genuine concerns in good faith.

The journal will not disadvantage a complainant in its editorial processes merely because that individual has raised a legitimate ethical concern.

Where the journal becomes aware of retaliatory conduct directly connected to its editorial activities, it may take appropriate action within the limits of its authority.

Malicious or Knowingly False Allegations

Whistleblower protections apply to individuals who raise concerns in good faith.

Knowingly false, malicious, fabricated, or deliberately misleading allegations may themselves constitute misconduct.

Where there is credible evidence that an allegation was intentionally fabricated or submitted for harassment, retaliation, or reputational damage, the journal may take appropriate action under its ethical policies.

A complaint will not be treated as malicious merely because it is ultimately unsubstantiated.

Investigation Process

The Editor-in-Chief normally oversees the initial screening of whistleblower reports.

Where appropriate, the matter may be handled by another independent editor if the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest.

The investigation process may include:

  • Reviewing the complaint and supporting documentation

  • Assessing whether the matter falls within the journal’s responsibility

  • Reviewing manuscript and publication records

  • Examining similarity reports where relevant

  • Reviewing data, figures, images, or supporting materials supplied to the journal

  • Examining peer review records and editorial correspondence

  • Requesting clarification from authors, reviewers, editors, or complainants

  • Consulting independent experts

  • Contacting research institutions, employers, funders, or ethics committees

  • Requesting an institutional investigation where appropriate

  • Issuing an editorial decision or publication notice based on available evidence

The journal will distinguish between matters it can investigate editorially and matters requiring formal investigation by an institution or another competent authority.

Conflicts of Interest in Misconduct Investigations

Any editor or editorial board member who has an actual, potential, or perceived conflict of interest relating to an allegation must not be responsible for investigating or deciding the matter.

Where the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict of interest, responsibility will be transferred to another suitably qualified and independent editor or adviser.

The journal will seek to ensure that allegations involving editors, reviewers, editorial board members, or individuals associated with JPM are evaluated independently.

Allegations Against Editors or Editorial Board Members

Allegations involving an editor, the Editor-in-Chief, or an editorial board member will be handled using the same principles of fairness, confidentiality, evidence, and independence applied to allegations involving authors or reviewers.

The individual concerned will not participate in the investigation or final decision relating to the allegation.

Where necessary, the journal may seek independent external advice or refer the matter to the relevant institution or authority.

Allegations Concerning Published Articles

Concerns relating to already published articles will be assessed even if they are raised after a significant period of time.

Where credible evidence indicates that the reliability, integrity, or ethical status of the publication may be affected, JPM may initiate a post-publication review.

The outcome may include:

  • No further action

  • A clarification

  • A correction

  • An Expression of Concern

  • A retraction

  • Referral to a relevant institution or authority

The appropriate action will depend on the nature and seriousness of the concern and the evidence available.

Communication of Outcomes

Where appropriate, the journal may inform relevant parties about the outcome of its assessment.

The level of information disclosed will depend on:

  • Confidentiality requirements

  • Data protection considerations

  • The nature of the allegation

  • Institutional involvement

  • Legal obligations

  • Publication-ethics considerations

The journal is not obliged to disclose confidential editorial correspondence, reviewer identities, institutional communications, or other protected information to a complainant.

Relationship to Other JPM Policies

This Research Misconduct & Whistleblower Policy should be read together with relevant JPM policies, including:

  • Publication Ethics Policy

  • Plagiarism Screening Policy

  • Peer Review Policy

  • Conflict of Interest Policy

  • Corrections and Retractions Policy

  • Author Credit Policy

  • Copyright and Licensing Policy

  • Author Guidelines

Where an allegation falls under more than one policy, the relevant provisions may be applied together.

Policy Review

JPM will periodically review this policy to maintain alignment with recognized standards of research integrity, publication ethics, COPE guidance, transparency principles, and developments in scholarly publishing.

Material changes to the journal’s procedures for handling misconduct or whistleblower reports will be reflected in the publicly available policy.

Contact

Editorial Office
Journal of Personnel Management (JPM)
Email: jpm@smarcons.com