Author Credit Policy

Advanced Psychological Research (APR), published by SMARCONS (Society of Management Research and Consultancy), is committed to transparency, accountability, fairness, and integrity in authorship and contributor recognition. The journal follows internationally recognized principles of publication ethics, including guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy).

APR recognizes that authorship must reflect substantial scholarly contributions rather than professional position, institutional authority, financial support, or administrative involvement. All individuals who meet the journal's authorship criteria must be appropriately credited, while contributors who do not qualify for authorship should be acknowledged.

1. Author Contributions (CRediT Taxonomy)

All authors are required to provide an accurate statement of their individual contributions using the CRediT (Contributor Roles Taxonomy).

The taxonomy includes the following 14 contributor roles:

  1. Conceptualization: Formulation or development of the overarching research goals, questions, and objectives.

  2. Methodology: Development or design of research methods, models, or procedures.

  3. Software: Programming, software development, implementation of computer code, or testing of existing code components.

  4. Validation: Verification of the reproducibility, reliability, or accuracy of research findings and outputs.

  5. Formal Analysis: Application of statistical, mathematical, computational, or other formal analytical techniques.

  6. Investigation: Conducting research activities, collecting data, or performing experiments and observations.

  7. Resources: Provision of study materials, instruments, participants, computing resources, or other essential research inputs.

  8. Data Curation: Management, organization, annotation, cleaning, preservation, or maintenance of research data.

  9. Writing – Original Draft: Preparation and writing of the initial manuscript.

  10. Writing – Review & Editing: Critical review, revision, and editing of the manuscript.

  11. Visualization: Preparation and presentation of figures, tables, graphs, or other visual research materials.

  12. Supervision: Oversight and leadership of research planning and implementation.

  13. Project Administration: Management and coordination of research activities and responsibilities.

  14. Funding Acquisition: Acquisition of financial support for the research project.

Authors may be assigned more than one CRediT role, and a role may be shared by multiple authors.

CRediT describes contributions but does not independently determine authorship eligibility. All listed authors must also satisfy the journal's authorship criteria.

The corresponding author must ensure that the contribution statement is accurate, approved by all authors, and submitted during the manuscript submission process. Approved contribution statements may be included in the published article.

2. Authorship Criteria

APR applies the following authorship criteria, consistent with widely recognized scholarly authorship principles and COPE guidance on authorship transparency.

To qualify as an author, an individual must meet all four conditions:

  1. Make substantial contributions to the conception or design of the research, or to the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of research data.

  2. Participate in drafting the manuscript or critically revising it for important intellectual content.

  3. Review and approve the final version of the manuscript before publication.

  4. Agree to be accountable for their contributions and cooperate in addressing questions concerning the accuracy, integrity, and reliability of the published work.

All four conditions must be satisfied.

Providing funding, collecting data without substantial intellectual contribution, general supervision, administrative support, or language editing alone does not automatically qualify an individual for authorship.

Individuals who contribute to the research but do not satisfy the authorship criteria should be appropriately recognized in the Acknowledgements section, with their permission.

3. Order of Authors

The order of authors must be determined collectively by the authors based on their scholarly contributions and disciplinary conventions.

APR does not prescribe a universal ranking of contributions or automatically assume that the first author made the greatest contribution.

The authors must agree on the authorship order before submission.

The corresponding author must confirm that:

  • All listed authors meet the authorship criteria.

  • All authors agree to their inclusion and position in the author list.

  • No eligible author has been excluded.

  • No individual has been included without a qualifying contribution.

  • All authors have approved the submitted manuscript and its final version.

Any proposed change to authorship after submission must be supported by a written explanation and the documented agreement of all affected authors, including individuals being added or removed.

The Editor-in-Chief may request additional documentation before approving an authorship change.

4. Acknowledgement of Non-Author Contributions

APR requires appropriate acknowledgement of individuals and organizations that contributed to the research without qualifying for authorship.

Examples include:

  • Administrative or technical assistance.

  • Language editing and proofreading.

  • Research coordination and logistical support.

  • General academic guidance.

  • Access to facilities, instruments, or research resources.

  • Financial or institutional support.

The corresponding author must obtain permission from individuals named in the Acknowledgements section.

Acknowledgements must not misrepresent the nature or extent of a contributor's involvement.

Funding sources must also be disclosed separately in the Funding Statement where applicable.

5. Ghost, Guest, and Honorary Authorship

APR strictly prohibits inappropriate authorship practices, including:

Ghost Authorship: Excluding an individual who satisfies the journal's authorship criteria or concealing substantial contributions that should be disclosed.

Guest Authorship: Including an individual primarily because of their professional reputation, academic standing, or perceived ability to increase the manuscript's acceptance prospects, without a qualifying scholarly contribution.

Honorary or Gift Authorship: Granting authorship as a courtesy, favor, or recognition of institutional authority rather than a genuine scholarly contribution.

Such practices are inconsistent with responsible scholarly publishing and may result in editorial investigation, rejection, correction, or retraction, as appropriate.

APR follows relevant COPE guidance on authorship and contributorship.

6. Use of Artificial Intelligence in Authorship and Manuscript Preparation

APR recognizes that artificial intelligence technologies may assist researchers with limited editorial activities. However, AI tools cannot satisfy authorship criteria and must not be listed as authors or co-authors.

Under APR's editorial policy:

  • AI-assisted tools may be used for grammar correction, spelling, and language refinement, subject to appropriate disclosure.

  • AI tools must not be used to generate substantive scholarly content, including literature reviews, original academic arguments, research findings, or interpretations.

  • AI-generated or fabricated research data, citations, references, results, and scholarly evidence are prohibited.

  • Authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, validity, and integrity of all submitted content.

  • Where AI-assisted tools have been used, authors must disclose their use in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines and Publication Ethics Policy.

  • Authors must protect confidential research information, unpublished manuscripts, and personally identifiable participant data when using digital or AI-assisted services.

APR refers to the COPE position on authorship and AI tools.

7. Corresponding Author Responsibilities

The corresponding author serves as the principal contact between the authors and APR throughout submission, peer review, publication, and post-publication communication.

The corresponding author is responsible for:

  • Managing communication with the editorial office.

  • Ensuring that all eligible authors are included in the manuscript.

  • Confirming that all authors approve the submitted and final versions.

  • Submitting accurate author names, affiliations, email addresses, and contributor statements.

  • Ensuring that funding, competing interests, ethics approvals, and research consent declarations are complete and accurate.

  • Coordinating responses to editorial and reviewer comments.

  • Ensuring that all authors are informed of relevant editorial decisions.

  • Submitting required authorship and contribution documentation.

  • Responding to reasonable post-publication inquiries.

  • Cooperating with investigations concerning research integrity, corrections, or authorship disputes.

The designation of a corresponding author does not remove the individual responsibilities of other authors.

8. Authorship Changes After Submission

Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must be submitted in writing to the editorial office.

The request must include:

  1. A clear explanation of the proposed change.

  2. An updated author contribution statement, where applicable.

  3. Written agreement from all listed authors and any authors being added or removed.

  4. Supporting documentation where requested by the editorial office.

Changes will be considered by the Editor-in-Chief in accordance with publication ethics principles.

Following publication, authorship changes will be evaluated through the journal's post-publication correction procedures and may require a formal correction notice.

APR reserves the right to suspend manuscript processing while unresolved authorship concerns are investigated.

9. Resolving Authorship Disputes

APR addresses authorship concerns fairly, confidentially, and consistently with relevant COPE guidance.

The journal may review author contribution statements and supporting documents, but it does not ordinarily adjudicate disputed factual claims about individual research contributions that require institutional investigation.

Step 1: Initial Complaint or Query

An authorship concern may be raised by:

  • A listed author.

  • An individual claiming wrongful inclusion or exclusion.

  • An institutional representative.

  • Another party presenting credible evidence of an authorship concern.

Complaints should be submitted in writing to apr@smarcons.com with available supporting documentation.

Step 2: Acknowledgement and Preliminary Assessment

The editorial office will acknowledge receipt of the complaint within five business days.

The Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately designated editor will assess the nature of the concern, whether additional information is required, and whether manuscript processing should be temporarily suspended.

Step 3: Collection of Written Statements

The journal may request written statements from the authors and other relevant parties addressing:

  • Individual research contributions.

  • Authorship eligibility.

  • Authorship order.

  • Agreement concerning the submitted manuscript.

  • Any disputed changes to the author list.

Relevant documentation may include author contribution forms, correspondence, institutional records, and manuscript revision histories.

Step 4: Referral to Relevant Institutions

When a dispute cannot be resolved through documented agreement, or credible concerns about research misconduct arise, APR may refer the matter to the relevant institution or research organization.

The journal will ordinarily defer determinations requiring investigation of disputed research contributions to the responsible institution.

Editorial processing may remain suspended while an institutional investigation is ongoing.

Step 5: Editorial Decision and Appropriate Action

Following review of the available evidence or institutional findings, APR may:

  • Resume manuscript processing when the concern has been satisfactorily resolved.

  • Approve an appropriately documented authorship correction.

  • Reject a manuscript when serious authorship misconduct is established or essential authorship requirements cannot be met.

  • Publish a correction, expression of concern, or retraction when warranted for a published article.

  • Decline further consideration of a manuscript where an unresolved authorship dispute prevents responsible editorial decision-making.

Post-publication actions will follow the journal's Post-Publication Correction and Retraction Policy and applicable COPE guidance.

Step 6: Communication and Documentation

The editorial office will maintain appropriate records of complaints, correspondence, documentation, and editorial decisions.

Relevant parties will be informed of decisions in writing, subject to confidentiality and applicable privacy requirements.

Step 7: Mediation, Where Appropriate

Where all relevant parties agree, APR may recommend institutional mediation or another independent dispute-resolution mechanism.

Mediation does not replace an institutional investigation when research misconduct is alleged.

The journal will avoid disclosing confidential information unnecessarily and will manage editorial conflicts of interest.

10. Authorship Roles and Administrative Responsibilities

The submitting author is the individual who completes the manuscript submission through the journal's submission system. The corresponding author is the designated contact for editorial and post-publication correspondence.

These roles may be performed by the same individual. They do not create separate levels of scholarly authorship or accountability.

Responsibility Submitting Author Corresponding Author
Entering manuscript and author metadata into the submission system ✓ As applicable
Uploading required manuscript files and documentation ✓ As applicable
Ensuring accurate author names and affiliations ✓ ✓
Confirming co-author approval ✓ ✓
Coordinating responses to reviewer comments As applicable ✓
Managing correspondence with the editorial office As applicable ✓
Ensuring required ethics and competing interest declarations are submitted ✓ ✓
Coordinating authorship contribution documentation ✓ ✓
Providing the published corresponding author email address   ✓
Responding to post-publication correspondence As applicable ✓
Cooperating with research integrity inquiries ✓ ✓

All authors remain accountable for their own scholarly contributions and must cooperate in resolving concerns about the integrity of the research.

11. Author Contribution Documentation

APR requires a contribution statement identifying each author's role using the CRediT taxonomy.

The corresponding author must ensure that the statement accurately reflects the contributions of all authors.

Authors must declare their agreement with the authorship information submitted to the journal.

APR may require a signed Author Contribution Form from all authors at submission or during editorial assessment, according to its published submission requirements.

Where the journal requires a signed form at initial submission, that requirement must also appear in the Author Guidelines and submission checklist.

12. Contact Information

For questions regarding authorship eligibility, contributor recognition, authorship changes, contribution documentation, or dispute resolution, please contact the editorial office:

Advanced Psychological Research (APR)

Email: apr@smarcons.com

All authors are expected to review and comply with this policy before manuscript submission. APR is committed to maintaining transparent and responsible authorship practices throughout the publication process.