Peer Review Policy

Peer Review Policy

Advanced Psychological Research (APR), published by SMARCONS (Society of Management Research and Consultancy), is committed to maintaining a rigorous, independent, fair, transparent, and ethical peer-review process to ensure the quality, originality, methodological soundness, and scholarly contribution of published research.

APR follows the principles of publication ethics and responsible peer review outlined by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the quality-control requirements established by the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ).

The journal uses double-blind peer review, under which the identities of authors are concealed from reviewers and the identities of reviewers are concealed from authors.

Every research article considered for publication must undergo evaluation by at least two qualified, independent reviewers before acceptance.

APR uses Open Journal Systems (OJS) to manage manuscript submissions, editorial screening, reviewer assignments, review reports, revisions, editorial decisions, and communication with authors and reviewers.

The journal aims to provide an initial editorial decision within 4–8 weeks, although actual processing times may vary depending on manuscript quality, reviewer availability, revision requirements, and the number of review rounds.

1. Initial Editorial Screening

All submitted manuscripts undergo preliminary evaluation by the Editor-in-Chief, Associate Editor, or an appropriately assigned handling editor.

The screening assesses whether the manuscript:

  • Falls within the aims and scope of APR.

  • Meets the journal's submission and formatting requirements.

  • Demonstrates originality and scholarly relevance.

  • Provides a sufficiently clear research problem and academic contribution.

  • Complies with the journal's publication ethics and authorship policies.

  • Includes required ethics approval, informed consent, and other research declarations where applicable.

  • Meets the minimum scholarly and methodological standards for external review.

The editorial office may use similarity-detection software to support originality screening. Similarity reports are evaluated by qualified editorial personnel, and no manuscript is rejected solely because of an automated similarity percentage without appropriate examination.

Manuscripts that are outside the journal's scope, inadequately prepared, ethically non-compliant, or insufficiently developed may be rejected during initial screening without external review.

Desk rejection decisions are communicated to the corresponding author.

2. External Peer Review

Manuscripts that successfully pass initial editorial screening are assigned to at least two qualified and independent reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript's subject matter and methodology.

Reviewers are selected based on:

  • Relevant academic qualifications.

  • Expertise in the research area.

  • Research and publication experience.

  • Knowledge of appropriate research methodologies.

  • Ability to provide a constructive and objective assessment.

  • Availability to complete the review.

  • Absence of actual or reasonably perceived conflicts of interest.

APR does not consider editorial screening or assessment by a single editor a substitute for the required independent peer reviews of research articles.

2.1. Double-Blind Review

APR employs double-blind peer review.

Authors must prepare anonymized manuscripts by removing identifying information, including author names, affiliations, acknowledgements, and other details that unnecessarily disclose author identity.

Reviewer identities are not disclosed to authors.

The editorial office takes reasonable precautions to preserve anonymity throughout the review process. However, complete anonymity cannot be guaranteed in every circumstance, particularly where authors have made their work publicly available as preprints.

2.2. Review Criteria

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts according to:

  • Originality and contribution to psychological research.

  • Relevance to APR's aims and scope.

  • Clarity of the research problem, objectives, and questions.

  • Strength of theoretical arguments and literature support.

  • Appropriateness of research design and methodology.

  • Sampling procedures and adequacy, where applicable.

  • Reliability, validity, credibility, and transparency of research methods and analyses.

  • Appropriate consideration of ethical requirements.

  • Clarity and accuracy of results.

  • Quality and balance of interpretation and discussion.

  • Alignment of conclusions with the evidence presented.

  • Appropriate use of citations and references.

  • Overall scholarly presentation, including tables, figures, and supplementary materials.

Reviewers are expected to provide constructive, objective, evidence-based, and respectful feedback.

3. Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers must:

  1. Maintain confidentiality concerning manuscript content and editorial correspondence.

  2. Declare actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest before accepting an invitation.

  3. Accept review assignments only when they possess the necessary expertise.

  4. Evaluate manuscripts objectively and professionally.

  5. Avoid personal criticism, discriminatory comments, or inappropriate language.

  6. Provide clear and constructive recommendations supported by scholarly reasoning.

  7. Identify relevant literature omissions where appropriate, without coercive citation requests.

  8. Notify the editor of suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated or falsified data, citation manipulation, ethical misconduct, or other integrity concerns.

  9. Complete reviews within the agreed period or promptly inform the editorial office of anticipated delays.

  10. Avoid using unpublished material or privileged information obtained through peer review for personal, academic, or commercial advantage.

  11. Refrain from sharing manuscript materials with unauthorized individuals.

  12. Inform the handling editor if they cannot provide an impartial assessment.

Reviewers must not contact manuscript authors directly regarding the review without authorization from the journal.

Reviewers should consult the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.

4. Editorial Responsibilities

Editors are responsible for conducting peer review fairly, independently, confidentially, and consistently with the journal's published procedures.

Editorial decisions are based on:

  • Scholarly originality and relevance.

  • Research quality and methodological rigor.

  • Reliability and transparency of findings.

  • Ethical compliance.

  • Constructive consideration of reviewer recommendations.

  • Alignment with the journal's scope and editorial standards.

Decisions must not be influenced by an author's nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, institutional affiliation, political beliefs, personal characteristics, or other irrelevant considerations.

The Editor-in-Chief holds final responsibility for editorial decisions, except where a conflict of interest requires the decision to be assigned to an independent qualified editor.

Editors may seek additional reviews, request clarification, invite revisions, reject a manuscript, or accept a manuscript once the required review process has been completed and publication standards are satisfied.

Editors must ensure that their own competing interests do not compromise editorial independence.

5. Editorial Decisions

Following evaluation of the required reviewer reports, the handling editor may recommend or issue one of the following decisions, subject to the journal's editorial authority:

  • Accept: The manuscript satisfies the journal's requirements and can proceed toward publication.

  • Minor Revision: Limited changes are required before further editorial assessment.

  • Major Revision: Substantial revisions are necessary to address scholarly, methodological, analytical, or presentation concerns.

  • Resubmit for Review: The revised manuscript requires further external assessment.

  • Reject: The manuscript does not satisfy the journal's publication requirements.

Authors receive the editorial decision together with relevant reviewer comments and editorial guidance.

Authors invited to revise must submit a revised manuscript and a point-by-point response indicating how reviewers' and editors' comments have been addressed.

Acceptance is not automatic following revision.

5.1. Disagreement Between Reviewers

Where reviewer recommendations differ substantially, the handling editor will evaluate the methodological reasoning, evidence, and relevance of the comments.

The editor may:

  • Request clarification from reviewers.

  • Seek an additional independent review.

  • Invite the authors to address specific concerns.

  • Make a reasoned editorial decision based on the complete review record.

An editorial decision is not determined solely through a numerical majority of reviewer recommendations.

6. Revisions and Re-Review

Authors must address editorial and reviewer comments thoroughly, professionally, and within the communicated revision period.

The revised manuscript should clearly identify substantive changes, and the accompanying response letter should address relevant comments individually.

Minor revisions may be evaluated by the handling editor.

Major revisions may be returned to the original reviewers or assigned to additional independent reviewers where necessary.

Editors may request further revision rounds when justified.

A manuscript may be accepted only after the required external reviews have been completed and the responsible editor determines that the journal's academic, methodological, ethical, and editorial requirements have been satisfied.

After acceptance, the manuscript proceeds through copyediting, proofreading, formatting, and production.

Substantive changes after acceptance require editorial approval. Corrections needed to address ethical, scientific, or technical concerns may be considered at any stage.

7. Confidentiality

All manuscripts submitted to APR are treated as confidential scholarly documents.

Editors, reviewers, editorial staff, and authorized individuals involved in manuscript assessment must protect:

  • Unpublished manuscript content.

  • Research data and supplementary materials.

  • Reviewer identities under the double-blind model.

  • Confidential reviewer reports.

  • Editorial correspondence.

  • Editorial decisions before authorized communication.

  • Personal information relating to authors and reviewers.

Manuscript materials must not be disclosed to unauthorized third parties.

Confidentiality obligations continue after the review process, subject to applicable legal requirements and legitimate research-integrity investigations.

8. Conflicts of Interest

Editors and reviewers must disclose any relationship or interest that could affect, or reasonably appear to affect, their impartiality.

Conflicts may include:

  • Financial or commercial interests.

  • Employment or institutional relationships.

  • Recent research collaborations.

  • Supervisory or mentorship relationships.

  • Personal or family relationships.

  • Academic competition.

  • Other circumstances that may compromise independent judgment.

Where a material conflict exists, the reviewer or editor must decline or withdraw from the assignment.

The manuscript will be reassigned to another suitably qualified and independent individual.

8.1. Manuscripts Submitted by Editors or Editorial Board Members

APR may consider manuscripts submitted by its editors, editorial board members, or reviewers, provided that editorial independence is fully protected.

Such manuscripts must:

  • Undergo the same quality-control procedures as other submissions.

  • Receive evaluation from at least two independent reviewers.

  • Be managed by an editor with no relevant conflict of interest.

  • Be excluded from the submitting editor's access to editorial deliberations and decisions.

  • Be assessed according to the same scholarly and ethical criteria as other manuscripts.

An editor must not manage, review, or make editorial decisions concerning their own manuscript.

APR monitors editorial and reviewer authorship within published issues to ensure that editorial participation does not compromise the independence of journal content.

The journal will comply with DOAJ's requirement that research papers involving editors, editorial board members, or reviewers do not exceed 25% of research papers in either of the latest two issues.

9. Artificial Intelligence and Automated Tools in Peer Review

APR recognizes that automated tools may assist certain administrative editorial activities, but human expertise, confidentiality, and accountability remain essential to scholarly evaluation.

9.1. Reviewers

Reviewers must not use generative artificial intelligence tools to produce their substantive peer-review assessments or replace their own critical scholarly judgment.

Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts, supplementary files, unpublished data, or editorial correspondence to publicly accessible or unauthorized AI systems.

Limited language editing of an independently prepared review may be permitted where confidentiality is protected and the use is disclosed to the handling editor.

Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, and integrity of their reports.

9.2. Editors

Editors must not delegate substantive editorial decisions to generative AI systems.

Any authorized automated assistance used for editorial administration, similarity screening, or research-integrity assessment must be subject to appropriate human oversight.

Automated findings, including plagiarism indicators, suspected image manipulation, or other integrity alerts, must be evaluated by qualified editorial personnel before decisions are made.

Routine journal use of automated tools should be disclosed where applicable.

Confidential manuscript information must not be entered into unauthorized AI platforms.

10. Peer-Review Integrity and Misconduct

APR is committed to preventing and addressing manipulation of the peer-review process.

Potential misconduct includes:

  • Fabricated reviewer identities.

  • False or misleading reviewer credentials.

  • Manipulated reviewer reports.

  • Peer-review rings or coordinated fraudulent reviewing.

  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest.

  • Coercive citation practices.

  • Breaches of confidentiality.

  • Unauthorized use of manuscript content.

  • Inappropriate or discriminatory reviewer conduct.

  • Misrepresentation of review completion or independence.

Where concerns arise, the editorial office may verify reviewer identities, request additional documentation, replace reviewers, commission additional independent reviews, or refer concerns for further investigation.

Depending on the outcome, APR may reject a manuscript, reconsider an editorial decision, issue a correction, publish an expression of concern, retract an article, or take another proportionate action under its publication ethics policies.

No allegation of misconduct will be treated as established solely on the basis of an unverified complaint or automated assessment.

11. Peer-Review Documentation and Record Retention

APR maintains appropriate records of its peer-review and editorial decision-making processes through OJS and, where necessary, authorized editorial archives.

Records may include:

  • Manuscript submission and revision histories.

  • Editorial screening and assignment records.

  • Reviewer invitations and responses.

  • Reviewer identities and relevant conflict-of-interest disclosures.

  • Reviewer reports and recommendations.

  • Editorial decisions and their rationale.

  • Author response letters.

  • Communications relating to appeals or research-integrity concerns.

These records support editorial accountability, quality assurance, and appropriate investigation of publication concerns.

Access is restricted to authorized personnel, subject to confidentiality, privacy, and applicable record-retention requirements.

APR does not ordinarily publish confidential reviewer identities or reports under its double-blind peer-review model.

12. Appeals and Complaints

Authors may appeal an editorial decision where they reasonably believe that it resulted from:

  • A significant procedural error.

  • An undisclosed conflict of interest.

  • A material misunderstanding of the manuscript.

  • A demonstrable error in the interpretation of evidence.

  • Another substantial concern affecting editorial fairness.

Appeals must be submitted in writing with a clear explanation and relevant supporting documentation.

The Editor-in-Chief, or an independent qualified editor where a conflict of interest exists, will assess the appeal.

The journal may seek additional independent advice or reviewer assessment when necessary.

An appeal does not automatically guarantee reconsideration or acceptance.

Authors will be informed of the outcome in writing. The journal's decision following the completion of its appeals procedure is final.

Complaints concerning editorial conduct, reviewer behavior, conflicts of interest, peer-review integrity, or publication ethics may be submitted to:

apr@smarcons.com

Complaints will be handled confidentially, fairly, and consistently with the journal's relevant ethical policies.

13. Special Issues

Where APR publishes special issues or collections managed by guest editors, all research articles must undergo the same scholarly, ethical, and external peer-review requirements as regular submissions.

Special-issue manuscripts must receive assessment by at least two qualified independent reviewers before acceptance.

The Editor-in-Chief retains overall responsibility for special-issue content.

Guest editors must:

  • Possess appropriate academic expertise.

  • Disclose relevant conflicts of interest.

  • Follow APR's editorial and ethical policies.

  • Protect reviewer independence and manuscript confidentiality.

  • Refrain from making decisions on submissions in which they have a conflict of interest.

Manuscripts submitted by guest editors must undergo independent editorial handling and external review.

Such manuscripts must not exceed 25% of the total articles published in the relevant special issue, consistent with DOAJ requirements.

Special-issue content must be clearly identified and remain within APR's aims and scope.

14. Manuscript Quality Standards

APR expects manuscripts to demonstrate:

  • A clear and relevant research problem.

  • Sound theoretical or conceptual grounding.

  • Appropriate engagement with scholarly literature.

  • A suitable and sufficiently rigorous research design.

  • Transparent data collection and analysis procedures.

  • Ethical compliance, including participant protections where applicable.

  • Clear presentation of findings.

  • Reasoned interpretation supported by evidence.

  • Balanced, accurate, and relevant referencing.

  • An original contribution to psychological research or related disciplines.

Appropriate evaluation criteria will be applied to different research approaches, including quantitative, qualitative, mixed-methods, theoretical, and review-based studies.

15. Acceptance Criteria

A manuscript may be accepted where it:

  • Falls within APR's aims and scope.

  • Demonstrates originality and scholarly significance.

  • Uses appropriate research methods or analytical approaches.

  • Presents sufficiently reliable, credible, or well-supported findings and arguments.

  • Complies with relevant ethical and publication requirements.

  • Has completed the required independent peer-review process.

  • Adequately addresses essential editorial and reviewer concerns.

  • Meets the journal's standards for scholarly presentation and reporting.

Final acceptance rests with the responsible editor and must be supported by the manuscript's quality and the completed review record.

16. Rejection Criteria

A manuscript may be rejected where it:

  • Falls outside APR's aims and scope.

  • Lacks sufficient originality or scholarly contribution.

  • Contains serious methodological, conceptual, or analytical weaknesses.

  • Presents unsupported, misleading, or unreliable conclusions.

  • Contains confirmed plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated data, falsified results, or other serious research-integrity violations.

  • Fails to comply with applicable human or animal research ethics requirements.

  • Contains unresolved authorship or competing-interest concerns that prevent responsible publication.

  • Does not adequately respond to essential reviewer or editorial concerns.

  • Fails to meet the journal's minimum scholarly or presentation standards.

Rejection decisions will be communicated to the corresponding author with appropriate editorial explanation.

17. Policy Review and Implementation

APR periodically reviews its peer-review procedures to maintain alignment with responsible scholarly publishing standards and developments in publication ethics.

The journal may revise these procedures when necessary to improve review quality, fairness, efficiency, confidentiality, or research integrity.

The editorial office is responsible for ensuring that publicly stated peer-review procedures accurately reflect the journal's actual editorial practices.

Changes to this policy will be published on the journal website.

18. Contact Information

For further information about the peer-review process, editorial decisions, appeals, or related ethical matters, authors may consult the journal's Author Guidelines and Publication Ethics Policy or contact:

Advanced Psychological Research (APR)

Publisher: SMARCONS (Society of Management Research and Consultancy)

Email: apr@smarcons.com

APR is committed to maintaining an independent, confidential, fair, transparent, and academically rigorous peer-review process that supports the integrity and credibility of published psychological research.