Peer Review Policy
1. Purpose and Scope
Applications of Mathematical Sciences (AMS) is a peer-reviewed, open-access scholarly journal published by the Society of Management Research and Consultancy (SMARCONS). The journal publishes original research articles, review articles, and short communications that advance knowledge in pure mathematics, applied mathematics, computational mathematics, mathematical modelling, statistics, numerical analysis, optimization, and related interdisciplinary fields.
AMS is committed to maintaining a rigorous, fair, independent, transparent, and ethically responsible peer-review process. The journal follows internationally recognized principles of scholarly publishing, including relevant guidance issued by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and the Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ).
The purpose of peer review is to evaluate the originality, mathematical correctness, methodological rigor, scholarly significance, clarity, reproducibility where applicable, and ethical integrity of submitted manuscripts.
Editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit, relevance to the journal's aims and scope, independent expert assessment, and compliance with publication ethics.
2. Peer-Review Model
AMS follows a double-blind peer-review process, under which:
-
Reviewers are not informed of the identities of the authors.
-
Authors are not informed of the identities of the reviewers.
-
Editors and authorized editorial staff have access to author identities for managing submissions and identifying potential conflicts of interest.
-
Reviewer reports and identities remain confidential and are not publicly released as part of the journal's standard review procedure.
Every original research article, review article, and short communication considered for acceptance must receive substantive evaluations from at least two independent external reviewers with appropriate subject expertise.
Invited scholarly research articles and invited review articles undergo the same independent external peer-review requirements as unsolicited submissions.
Book reviews and non-research editorial material may undergo editorial assessment rather than external peer review. Such content must be clearly identified by article type and must not be misrepresented as externally peer-reviewed research.
Manuscripts may be rejected during initial editorial screening without external review if they do not satisfy the journal's requirements.
An invitation to revise does not constitute acceptance or guarantee publication.
3. Preparation for Double-Blind Review
Authors must prepare manuscripts in accordance with the journal's Author Guidelines.
Submissions should include:
-
Separate Title Page: Containing the manuscript title, author names, institutional affiliations, corresponding-author contact information, ORCID identifiers where available, and relevant declarations.
-
Anonymized Manuscript: Containing the research content without author names, institutional affiliations, acknowledgements, or unnecessary identifying details.
-
Supplementary Materials: Including datasets, computational programs, mathematical appendices, algorithms, additional proofs, or other research materials where applicable.
Authors should remove identifying document metadata and cite their previous publications in the third person without omitting necessary scholarly references.
Supplementary materials essential for evaluating the validity of the manuscript's claims are provided to reviewers where confidentiality, legal permissions, and technical feasibility permit. Editors may arrange additional specialist assessment when necessary.
Preprints and publicly available research materials may sometimes reveal author identities. Reviewers who recognize an author's identity must inform the handling editor if this presents an actual or potential conflict of interest.
Reviewers must not deliberately investigate authors' identities.
4. Initial Editorial Screening
Every submitted manuscript undergoes an initial editorial assessment conducted by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated handling editor.
The assessment considers:
-
Alignment with the journal's aims and scope.
-
Originality and significance of the mathematical contribution.
-
Clarity of the research problem, mathematical formulation, or objectives.
-
Adequacy of mathematical reasoning and methodological presentation.
-
Compliance with author guidelines.
-
Appropriate citation and acknowledgment of earlier research.
-
Potential plagiarism, redundant publication, fabrication, falsification, or other research-integrity concerns.
-
Completeness of authorship, funding, competing interests, ethical approval, and data or code availability declarations, where applicable.
Similarity-detection tools and other editorial assessment methods may be used.
Similarity findings are evaluated in context. A particular similarity percentage alone does not establish plagiarism or research misconduct.
Following screening, a manuscript may be returned for technical correction, rejected without external review, or forwarded for independent peer review.
5. Selection and Independence of Reviewers
Reviewers are selected by the handling editor according to their expertise in the manuscript's mathematical subject, research methods, and relevant applications.
Interdisciplinary manuscripts may require reviewers with complementary expertise.
Reviewers must be sufficiently independent of the authors and free from conflicts of interest that could reasonably influence their judgment.
Potential conflicts include:
-
Current employment at the same institution as an author.
-
Recent coauthorship, collaboration, or joint research funding.
-
Supervisory or close mentoring relationships.
-
Close personal relationships or significant professional disputes.
-
Financial interests connected to the research.
-
Direct involvement in the submitted work.
Reviewers must disclose actual or potential conflicts before accepting an invitation and promptly report newly identified conflicts.
The handling editor evaluates such disclosures and appoints alternative reviewers where independence may reasonably be questioned.
Authors may suggest suitable reviewers or identify individuals they believe have conflicts of interest, with appropriate explanations.
The editor independently verifies reviewer suitability, identity, expertise, and potential conflicts. The journal is not obliged to appoint author-suggested reviewers.
Fabricated reviewer identities, false contact information, manipulated reviewer recommendations, or attempts to compromise peer review are treated as potential publication misconduct.
6. Manuscript Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers assess each manuscript according to its research type and mathematical contribution.
Pure theoretical mathematics is not required to include experimental datasets, empirical hypotheses, or numerical validation where these are not relevant to the research objectives.
6.1 General Evaluation Criteria
Reviewers consider:
Originality: Whether the manuscript makes an identifiable contribution to mathematical knowledge.
Mathematical Correctness: Whether mathematical statements, proofs, equations, derivations, algorithms, and conclusions are valid.
Scientific Rigor: Whether assumptions, procedures, reasoning, and analytical methods are sufficiently justified.
Scholarly Significance: Whether the results meaningfully advance theory, methodology, computation, or applications.
Clarity and Presentation: Whether definitions, symbols, notation, explanations, figures, and tables are presented clearly and consistently.
Literature and Attribution: Whether the manuscript accurately acknowledges previous contributions and situates its findings within relevant mathematical literature.
Transparency: Whether research limitations, assumptions, computational procedures, supporting materials, competing interests, and ethical considerations are adequately disclosed.
Reviewers must not require unnecessary citations intended primarily to increase citations to themselves, the journal, its editors, or the publisher.
6.2 Theoretical Mathematics
For theoretical mathematics manuscripts, reviewers assess whether:
-
Mathematical definitions, assumptions, and theorem statements are precise.
-
Proofs are logically valid and sufficiently complete.
-
Lemmas, propositions, and previously established results are correctly applied.
-
Domains of validity, boundary conditions, and exceptions are appropriately addressed.
-
Novelty is established through comparison with existing mathematical results.
-
Examples and counterexamples support relevant arguments.
-
Conjectures, heuristic arguments, and proven results are clearly distinguished.
Computer-assisted proofs should explain the computational component sufficiently for independent scrutiny, including relevant algorithms, verification procedures, software, and error controls.
6.3 Computational and Numerical Mathematics
For computational and numerical research, reviewers evaluate:
-
Clarity and reproducibility of mathematical algorithms.
-
Adequacy of computational methods and implementation details.
-
Validity of claims concerning convergence, stability, consistency, accuracy, or computational complexity.
-
Suitability of numerical benchmarks and comparative methods.
-
Reporting of relevant parameters, initial and boundary conditions, tolerances, stopping criteria, and software versions.
-
Appropriateness of error analysis, sensitivity analysis, and uncertainty assessment.
-
Availability of supporting code, data, and instructions, or a justified explanation of access restrictions.
-
Consistency between computational evidence and the conclusions presented.
Numerical agreement alone does not establish mathematical proof.
Claims of computational superiority must be supported by appropriate evidence and clearly identified evaluation conditions.
6.4 Applied Mathematics and Mathematical Modelling
Reviewers assess whether:
-
The mathematical problem and its practical relevance are clearly explained.
-
Model assumptions and limitations are justified.
-
Equations, variables, constraints, units, and parameters are appropriate.
-
Analytical, numerical, or statistical techniques are suitable.
-
Validation is provided where relevant to the manuscript's claims.
-
Parameter estimation, identifiability, sensitivity, and uncertainty are adequately considered where applicable.
-
Mathematical findings are distinguished from broader claims about the application domain.
-
Applicable ethical, privacy, data-permission, or regulatory requirements are addressed.
Research presenting a theoretical mathematical model is not automatically required to include empirical validation. However, its conclusions must remain consistent with the evidence and theoretical reasoning provided.
6.5 Review Articles and Short Communications
Review articles must provide a critical, accurate, and meaningful synthesis of the relevant mathematical literature.
Systematic reviews should report transparent and sufficiently reproducible literature-search, screening, and selection procedures.
Short communications must present a focused and substantive scholarly contribution, supported by sufficient methodological explanation, mathematical reasoning, and evidence.
Short communications are subject to the same standards of peer-review independence and research integrity as full research articles.
7. Reviewer Responsibilities and Confidentiality
Reviewers must:
-
Accept assignments only when they possess appropriate expertise.
-
Disclose conflicts of interest.
-
Provide objective, constructive, evidence-based, and respectful assessments.
-
Explain substantive criticisms clearly.
-
Distinguish essential revisions from optional recommendations.
-
Identify suspected mathematical errors or research-integrity concerns.
-
Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts, supplementary materials, reviewer reports, and editorial correspondence.
-
Refrain from using unpublished ideas, methods, data, or findings for personal or professional advantage.
-
Complete reviews within the agreed period or promptly request an extension.
Reviewers must not disclose confidential material or involve another person in the review without prior editorial authorization.
Any approved review contributor must comply with equivalent confidentiality and conflict-of-interest requirements.
Under the journal's standard double-blind model, reviewer identities and reports are not published with individual articles.
Any general acknowledgment of reviewer contributions requires appropriate consent and must not identify reviewers associated with particular manuscripts.
8. Artificial Intelligence and Automated Tools
AMS maintains strict safeguards concerning the use of artificial intelligence during editorial assessment and peer review.
Reviewers and editors must not upload confidential manuscripts, supplementary materials, peer-review reports, or editorial correspondence to public or unauthorized generative AI services.
Generative AI must not replace expert scholarly judgment or independently produce substantive peer-review assessments.
Reviewers and editors remain personally responsible for the accuracy, reasoning, confidentiality, and integrity of their evaluations.
Any approved automated tools must operate under appropriate confidentiality safeguards and human editorial oversight.
Automated indications of plagiarism, manipulated research material, unreliable references, or other integrity concerns must be evaluated by qualified individuals before editorial action.
Authors must comply with the journal's separate Publication Ethics Policy concerning generative AI.
Routine language-editing assistance must not be used to misrepresent authorship or originality. AI-generated mathematical proofs, fabricated references, invented results, or unverified computational findings must not be presented as authentic scholarly contributions.
AI systems cannot be listed as authors.
9. Editorial Decisions
The handling editor evaluates reviewer reports together with the manuscript's scholarly quality and compliance with journal policies.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. Editorial decisions are not determined by a simple vote among reviewers.
Possible decisions are:
Accept: The manuscript meets the journal's scholarly, ethical, and publication requirements.
Minor Revision: Limited corrections, clarification, or improvements are required.
Major Revision: Substantial changes are needed before the manuscript can be reconsidered.
Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements, or significant concerns cannot reasonably be addressed through revision.
Authors receive the editorial decision and relevant reviewer comments.
Where reviewer reports conflict or important scientific questions remain unresolved, the editor may request clarification or appoint additional independent reviewers.
Final editorial decisions are made by qualified, unconflicted editors.
Author nationality, institutional affiliation, personal characteristics, commercial considerations, and financial circumstances must not influence decisions.
AMS does not charge publication fees, and editorial decisions are independent of financial interests.
10. Revision and Further Review
Authors invited to revise a manuscript must submit:
-
A revised manuscript.
-
A point-by-point response to reviewer and editorial comments.
-
A clear explanation or identification of manuscript changes.
-
Reasoned responses where particular recommendations have not been adopted.
Major revisions normally return to the original reviewers where available.
Alternative or additional reviewers may be appointed when necessary.
Minor revisions may be assessed by the handling editor or returned for further independent review, depending on the nature of the changes.
Revision deadlines are communicated through the journal's editorial system.
Authors may request extensions where reasonable.
If authors do not respond after a reminder and a clearly communicated deadline, the editorial office may close the submission and notify the corresponding author.
Acceptance requires satisfactory resolution of substantive scholarly concerns and completion of applicable editorial and integrity checks.
11. Editorial Independence and Submissions by Journal Members
AMS is committed to editorial independence and preventing excessive publication of articles authored by individuals involved in journal management or peer review.
Submissions authored by editors, editorial board members, reviewers, or individuals associated with the publisher receive no preferential treatment.
Such manuscripts must be managed by an independent, appropriately qualified editor who has no relevant conflict of interest.
Author-editors must not participate in reviewer selection, editorial deliberations, or decisions concerning their own submissions.
Where the Editor-in-Chief is an author or has a relevant conflict, editorial responsibility must be transferred to another qualified and unconflicted editor.
AMS monitors editorial-board and reviewer authorship in published issues.
In accordance with DOAJ eligibility criteria, research articles with at least one author who is an editor, editorial board member, or reviewer of the journal must not exceed 25% of research articles in either of the journal's latest two issues.
For publication models without conventional issues, the journal will apply the corresponding DOAJ assessment period.
The journal also ensures that editorial and peer-review decisions remain independent of commercial, institutional, or publisher influence.
12. Special Issues and Guest Editors
Special issues, where published, must remain consistent with the journal's aims and scope.
The Editor-in-Chief retains ultimate editorial responsibility for all journal content, including special issues.
Guest editors must possess appropriate academic qualifications and subject expertise. Their credentials and potential conflicts of interest are assessed before appointment.
The Editor-in-Chief or designated independent editorial board members oversee the work of guest editors.
Special-issue research articles must undergo the same independent external peer-review process as regular research articles, including substantive assessment by at least two independent external reviewers.
Submissions authored by guest editors must be handled by independent editors who are not involved in the submission.
Articles authored by guest editors must not exceed 25% of the total articles in the special issue.
Special-issue articles must be clearly identified.
Special issues must not be used to bypass editorial scrutiny, compromise reviewer independence, or guarantee acceptance.
AMS will also ensure that special-issue publication practices remain consistent with applicable DOAJ requirements.
13. Appeals and Complaints
Authors may appeal editorial decisions when they believe that a significant factual error, misunderstanding, procedural irregularity, or conflict of interest affected the decision.
Appeals must be submitted through the official editorial contact and should include a clear explanation and supporting evidence.
Where practicable, appeals are reviewed by an appropriately qualified editor who was not responsible for the original decision.
Additional independent advice may be obtained where necessary.
The editorial office communicates the outcome and its rationale to the corresponding author.
An appeal does not guarantee reversal of a decision or acceptance of a manuscript.
Complaints concerning reviewer conduct, editorial ethics, confidentiality, conflicts of interest, or peer-review integrity may also be submitted to the journal.
An individual who is the subject of a complaint must not be its sole adjudicator.
Complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief are referred to an appropriate unconflicted representative of the Society of Management Research and Consultancy (SMARCONS).
Editorial contact: ams@smarcons.com
14. Research Integrity and Post-Publication Concerns
AMS investigates credible concerns relating to scholarly integrity or peer-review manipulation.
Concerns may include plagiarism, fabricated or falsified findings, compromised reviewer identities, undisclosed competing interests, invalid mathematical proofs, misleading computational results, or unethical research practices.
The journal may temporarily pause the editorial process while obtaining explanations, relevant evidence, or independent expert assessments.
Affected authors and other relevant participants are provided an appropriate opportunity to respond.
Depending on the outcome, editorial actions may include requests for correction, further peer review, manuscript rejection, or withdrawal of acceptance before publication.
Concerns identified after publication are addressed through the journal's Publication Ethics Policy and Corrections and Retractions Policy.
Appropriate actions may include publication of corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or other transparent editorial notices.
15. Peer-Review Timelines
AMS aims to communicate the first editorial decision following external peer review within approximately 8–10 weeks of manuscript submission.
This is an indicative editorial target, not a guaranteed processing period.
Actual review times may vary according to:
-
Manuscript complexity.
-
Availability of qualified independent reviewers.
-
Requirements for additional mathematical verification.
-
Requests for supporting data, computational evidence, or clarification.
-
The need for further specialist assessment.
Initial editorial screening decisions may be communicated earlier.
Manuscripts requiring revision or additional review may take longer to receive a final decision.
The stated 8–10-week target does not represent a guaranteed time to acceptance or publication.
Where significant delays occur, authors will be informed of the circumstances and may contact the editorial office to discuss the submission's status or request withdrawal.
AMS does not guarantee acceptance within any specified timeframe.
16. Acceptance, Production, and Editorial Records
Following final acceptance, manuscripts undergo appropriate production checks, copyediting, typesetting, and proof preparation.
Authors are normally provided with proofs to review typographical, formatting, and necessary technical corrections.
Substantive changes to mathematical proofs, methods, results, interpretations, or conclusions after acceptance require editorial authorization and may necessitate additional peer review.
AMS maintains confidential records of:
-
Reviewer invitations and assignments.
-
Reviewer reports.
-
Editorial decisions.
-
Manuscript revisions.
-
Relevant conflict-of-interest declarations.
-
Editorial correspondence and decisions concerning research integrity.
Published research articles display their manuscript received date, accepted date, and publication date.
The journal maintains publication records in accordance with applicable editorial, preservation, and research-integrity requirements.
17. Transparency and Policy Compliance
AMS publishes its peer-review policy to inform authors, reviewers, readers, and relevant indexing organizations about its editorial procedures.
The journal is committed to applying its published policies consistently.
Any substantial amendment to peer-review procedures will be reflected on the journal website.
The peer-review process should remain consistent with the journal's:
-
Author Guidelines.
-
Publication Ethics Policy.
-
Authorship and Contributorship Policy.
-
Conflicts of Interest Policy.
-
Corrections and Retractions Policy.
-
Complaints and Appeals procedures.
In the event of a policy inconsistency, the editorial office will examine the relevant provisions and clarify the applicable procedure transparently.
Published editorial policies must accurately reflect actual journal practices.
18. Contact Information
For questions about manuscript evaluation, peer-review procedures, reviewer responsibilities, editorial decisions, appeals, or complaints, authors and reviewers may contact:
Editorial Office
Applications of Mathematical Sciences (AMS)
Publisher: Society of Management Research and Consultancy (SMARCONS)
Email: ams@smarcons.com
Journal Website: https://journals.smarcons.com/index.php/ams/
Online Submission: https://journals.smarcons.com/index.php/ams/about/submissions
AMS is committed to maintaining a fair, independent, transparent, and academically rigorous peer-review process that safeguards research integrity and contributes to the advancement of mathematical sciences.