Gen Z, Quiet Quitting, and Organizational Commitment: A Dual-Pathway Theory of Effort–Commitment Decoupling
Keywords:
Generation Z; quiet quitting; organizational commitment; social exchange theory; self-determination theory; psychological contract; work-role boundariesAbstract
Quiet quitting has become a prominent label for employees who meet their formal obligations while limiting discretionary effort. Yet the label creates a theoretical puzzle: identical role-bounded behavior may indicate deteriorating organizational attachment or a sustainable attempt to preserve it. This conceptual paper examines that puzzle in the context of Generation Z without assuming that cohort membership determines work values. Through purposive, critical integration of peer-reviewed research on quiet quitting, organizational commitment, social exchange, self-determination, and work-role boundaries, the paper develops an effort–commitment decoupling framework. Social exchange theory explains whether employees interpret optional contributions as reciprocated or exploited; self-determination theory explains whether regulating extra-role effort expresses autonomous self-governance or defensive withdrawal. The framework proposes two routes to outwardly similar behavior: breach-driven recalibration, associated with erosion of affective commitment, and autonomy-preserving boundary stewardship, potentially compatible with durable commitment. Continuance constraints and managers’ interpretations of role boundaries qualify these paths, and misrecognition can transform protective restraint into genuine disengagement over time. Six propositions specify antecedents, mechanisms, commitment trajectories, and feedback. The main contribution is to locate quiet quitting neither automatically inside commitment nor automatically outside it, but at the contested boundary between agreed role requirements and discretionary labor. For research, this implies measuring behavior, motive, role legitimacy, and commitment separately; for practice, it favors negotiated expectations and autonomy-supportive management over generational labeling or indiscriminate demands for extra effort.